An arthritic joint isn't one problem. It's three things feeding each other: the pain signal, the inflammation burning inside the joint, and the breakdown of cartilage that inflammation drives.
Sort the natural list by which one it touches:
Glucosamine, chondroitin, hyaluronic acid, most joint chews — raw materials for cartilage. Bricks. The evidence in cats is thin, and bricks don't help a building that's on fire.
CBD and hemp — aimed at the pain signal. Some owners report calmer, more comfortable cats. I've never seen a controlled trial in arthritic cats.
MCT oil, rosehip, herbal blends — may well be harmless. Same problem: no trials in arthritic cats that I can point you to.
Marine omega-3 — EPA and DHA — aimed at the inflammation itself. And the only one on the list with placebo-controlled trials in cats with confirmed arthritis.
That's the whole reason the drawer fills up. Most of the natural shelf is bricks, or guesses. The fire inside the joint — the thing causing the pain and the damage — burns on untouched.
She's taking a supplement every day, and she still won't jump on the bed.
Because inflammation is the lever almost nothing on that list pulls.